Categories
Climate & Ocean Action Home News Ocean Conservation

Deep-Sea Mining: A Financial gamble Africa cannot afford


In Accra’s bustling Makola Market, the daily chatter reflects the struggles and hopes of Ghana’s coastal communities. Fishermen like Kojo Mensah, who has been navigating the Atlantic waves for decades, voice growing concerns over the future of their livelihoods. “If the fish disappear because of some mining we don’t even understand, what will my children eat? What will they do?” he asks, his weathered hands gesturing towards the ocean.

Kojo’s fears are echoed across Africa as the debate around deep-sea mining (DSM) intensifies. Proponents tout its potential to boost economies by extracting valuable minerals from the ocean floor. Yet, for many African nations, the financial promises of DSM appear eerily similar to the unfulfilled dreams of terrestrial mining, which has left a trail of environmental destruction and economic inequities.


Learning from the Past

Africa’s history with terrestrial mining is a cautionary tale. In the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) and Zambia—Africa’s largest copper producers—mismanagement, corruption, and pollution have cost nations billions. The DRC alone has lost an estimated $3.7 billion due to malpractice in the mining sector. Far from being a pathway to prosperity, mining has often enriched foreign corporations while devastating local ecosystems and communities.

DSM threatens to replicate these patterns on a massive scale. The Democratic Republic of Congo, Zambia, Namibia, and Zimbabwe are among the African nations most likely to feel the economic ripple effects of DSM. A 2020 study commissioned by the International Seabed Authority (ISA) revealed that DSM could disrupt the global supply chain, undermining the export-dependent economies of these nations.

“Countries like Zambia and the DRC could lose up to 79% of their export income if DSM causes a global glut in minerals like copper and cobalt,” warns Professor Mensah Anani, an economist specializing in resource governance. These losses would not only erode GDP but also threaten jobs and public services that are already stretched thin.


The Cost of False Promises

Despite its branding as a global solution to mineral shortages, DSM presents significant financial risks for African nations. The ISA, responsible for governing DSM activities, initially promised equitable benefits for developing states. Yet, these promises are undermined by glaring gaps in policy and practice.

For instance, contractors often negotiate agreements that exempt them from corporate income tax, further slashing the potential revenue for sponsoring states. Moreover, the high costs of DSM technology, environmental impact assessments, and regulatory oversight mean that any returns would likely be consumed by operational expenses.

Even the ISA’s own operational arm, The Enterprise, faces substantial limitations. Established to ensure fair participation by developing states, its dependence on joint ventures with private corporations significantly curtails its autonomy. “The profits, if any, will trickle down, not flow,” says Dr. Emmanuel Ofori, a marine governance expert.


Ecological and Economic Domino Effects

Beyond the financial risks, DSM poses a direct threat to Africa’s marine ecosystems, which are vital for food security and economic stability. Coastal states like Ghana, where tuna fishing accounts for a significant portion of export revenue, could see catastrophic impacts. Sediment plumes and noise pollution from mining operations are expected to disrupt fish habitats, potentially contaminating food chains and reducing fish stocks.

In Seychelles, where tuna exports make up nearly 90% of merchandise trade, the stakes are even higher. “Our oceans are our lifeline,” explains Seychelles-based environmentalist Rose Beauchamp. “If DSM undermines our fisheries, it’s not just an economic issue—it’s an existential one.”


Lessons from Climate Action

As Africa grapples with the realities of climate change, DSM represents a step in the wrong direction. The continent’s coastlines and marine ecosystems, already under threat from rising sea levels and illegal fishing, cannot afford the additional strain. Initiatives like the Moroni Declaration and the Nairobi Declaration emphasize the importance of protecting these ecosystems for climate resilience and economic security.

DSM, however, threatens to undo these efforts. The disturbance of deep-sea ecosystems, crucial for carbon sequestration, could exacerbate climate change, making Africa even more vulnerable to its effects.


The Way Forward

Rather than plunging into the uncertain depths of DSM, African nations should champion sustainable marine practices that align with global frameworks like the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals and the Paris Agreement. Investing in blue economy initiatives, such as marine biotechnology and sustainable fisheries, offers a path to prosperity without sacrificing environmental integrity.

“The ocean is our heritage and our future,” says Kojo Mensah, his gaze fixed on the horizon. For him and millions of Africans who depend on the sea, the risks of DSM are too great, the rewards too uncertain.

As the global community debates the merits of deep-sea mining, Africa must lead with caution, prioritizing the well-being of its people and ecosystems over short-term profits. The lessons of the past are clear: the true cost of exploitation is borne by those who can least afford it.

Report by Akwesi Appiah, This report was supported by SOA Ghana Hub

css.php